• 010 140 5777
  • admin@sandpattorneys.co.za
    SCHEEPERS LOGOS&P logoSCHEEPERS LOGOSCHEEPERS LOGO
    • Home
    • Who We Are
    • What We Do
      • Debt Collections
      • Debt Reviews
      • Corporate Law
      • Correspondent Services
      • Criminal Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Family Law
      • Labour Law
    • Articles
    • Contact
    Scam Alert
    March 6, 2017
    Selecting the right Criminal defense Attorney
    September 5, 2017
    Published by ffrwd at May 30, 2017
    Categories
    • Articles
    Tags
    • Scheepers Pretorius Attorneys
    • top law firm

     

    These three theories of punishment in criminal law have shaped the way the world seeks retribution.

    3 Theories of punishment in South African Criminal Law

    The idea behind criminal law is to provide a mechanism whereby offenders of the criminal justice system receive an appropriate punishment for misconduct that is to be delivered by the authority of the state. Having said that, the business of delivering justice is not clear cut, there is no objectively good way of going about it.

    Because of this, multiple theories surrounding the delivery of punishment with regards to the South African justice system have come about. Here are the three most popular, which affect the direction and outcome of criminal cases in our country.

    Retributive theories of punishment

    Retributive theories of punishment, otherwise known as absolute theories, work on the age-old notion of ‘an eye for an eye’, and in doing so, seek to correct upsets in legal balances that have come about as a result of a committed crime; making it one of the oldest approaches to criminal punishment in existence.

    The theory places careful emphasis on taking care not to confuse retribution with vengeance, claiming that retribution is an enlightened attempt to restore imbalances caused by criminal misconduct, while vengeance is simply seeking revenge in a personal or private capacity.

    This theory claims that retribution is the essential characteristic of punishment, and so sees no point in justifying a means by its ends. Still, it generally takes an offender’s track record into account.

    Utilitarian theories of punishment

    Utilitarian, or relative theories of punishment, can be subdivided into three different categories: prevention, deterrence and reformation.

    These theories are often associated with extreme punishments such as capital punishment or castration, or in less extreme examples can be seen in the confiscation of firearms or drivers licences.

    Preventative punishment is handed down by the state in an attempt to prevent the occurrence of further crimes; whether that be through house arrest, incarceration or confiscation of goods.

    Deterrent theories are those that posit a punishment should deter the future undertaking of a crime, either by the guilty individual themselves, or by the community at large.

    The reformative approach to punishment serves to eliminate the possibility of warped sentences being imposed on offenders who do not deserve them. Instead of jail cells being filled with minor-offenders, this approach takes a social approach by having offenders do community service.

    Combination theories of punishment

    Since each of these theories have both positive and negative impacts on the South African justice system, many theorists have found benefits in combining their strengths into a unified theory of punishment.

    Combination theories look out for those aspects of punishment that are best suited to the interests of society, the actual offender, and the nature of the crime, which has proven to be the best approach in terms of South African criminal law.

    If you would like to find out more about criminal law, or seek legal advice from a professional attorney, contact Scheepers Pretorius, or visit our website for details.

    Share
    0
    ffrwd
    ffrwd

    Related posts

    August 7, 2018

    I Won My Dispute But I Am Not Getting Paid


    Read more
    August 7, 2018

    Dealing With Criminal Charges For Marijuana Possession


    Read more
    June 7, 2018

    How to Help a Victim of Domestic Violence


    Read more

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    call

    Contact Us

    Email: admin@sandpattorneys.co.za

    Tel : 010-140-5777

    24h Bail : 082 853 7318

    clock

    Business hours

    Monday - Thursday
    8h00-16h30
    Fridays
    8h00-15h00


    location

    Roodepoort Office

    Gables Office estate, Building 8, 879 Tennis Rd, Weltevredenpark, Roodepoort, 1715

    Randburg Office

    The Oaks Office Park, Unit 8, 368 Oak Avenue, Randburg, 2194

    Pretoria Office

    570 Fehrsen Street, Brooklyn Bridge Office Park, 3rd Floor Steven House, Pretoria, 0181 (Click Here for Pretoria branch contact and service info)

    Copyright © 2020 Scheepers Pretorius Inc. All Rights Reserved